The Plight of Construction Workers in Dubai .

jezebel.com

5 Views

        

Before we begin: modern slavery in Dubai is something that I’ve written about before. In my previous article, I gave an overview of the conditions that migrant workers in Dubai have to deal with and why this amounts to modern day slavery before questioning why tourists continue to flock to Dubai despite its shocking human rights violations. If you’re new to the topic of slavery in Dubai then I suggest you check out that article first (which you can do here), before coming back to this one.

In this article I will be digging a little deeper and focusing specifically on the treatment of construction workers in Dubai, the shocking abuses they incur as well as delving into the legal system that is stacked against them

Got that? Okay, so let’s begin. 

Picture Dubai and what do you see? My guess is high rise buildings, luxury resorts and prime real estate. In fact, not only is Dubai home to the world’s only ‘7-star’ hotel, but the tallest as well, and with 168 hotel projects in the pipeline as of 2017, it doesn’t seem to be slowing down any time soon. 

However, it hasn’t always been that way. As recently as 1990, Dubai was little more than a desert with its main strip, Sheikh Zayed Road possessing only a couple of buildings with sandy plains stretching as far as the eye can see. 

sheikh Zayed Road, Dubai before construction boom
Sheikh Zayed Road in the early 90s. IMG: Wikimedia Commons
dubai bird's eye view from Burj Khalifa
Dubai today

IMG: Unsplash. Arham Awan.

Fast-forward just a few short years and the United Arab Emirates – in particular the Emirate of Dubai – is one of the biggest and fastest growing construction markets in the world, with at least half a million migrant construction workers being employed in Dubai alone. 

THE NUMBERS

Migrant Workers in Dubai 

The United Arab Emirates has a colossal number of migrant workers, with foreigners making up a whopping 88.5% of the total workforce in the UAE – a total of around 8 million people. In fact, the private sector (the part of the economy which is run by individuals and private companies and is not state controlled) is comprised of 99.5% migrant workers (!), meaning the UAE’s economy depends entirely on the migrant workforce and the value that they provide. 

Of these migrant workers in the UAE, 20% of those are construction workers who are overwhelmingly men from South Asian countries (namely India, Pakistan, Bangladesh and Sri Lanka) who are illiterate and from impoverished rural communities. They come to Dubai in search of a better life after being promised food, accommodation and good salaries* in exchange for 9-5 construction work 5 days a week. 

dubai
The dream

IMG: Unsplash, Roman Logov.

THE PROCESS 

How Do Migrant Workers in Dubai End up As Slaves? 

The process of recruiting foreigners as slaves in Dubai is really very similar to that of modern day slavery and human trafficking all around the world. 

First, you create a dream to be sold. With a city like Dubai, that is not hard to do. You simply show glittering panoramic shots of the skyline, dangling the luxury of Dubai on a thread and emphasising the huge salaries and excellent quality of life that is yours to enjoy in this adult playground. Dubai has marketed itself for years as a cosmopolitan paradise where dreams are made, and so it isn’t difficult to convince a poverty-stricken man from rural Bangladesh who is struggling to feed his family that life in Dubai must be better.

Next, you have to sell that dream. Agencies in the victims’ home countries advertise the so-called ‘opportunities’ in Dubai and charge the victims 2000-3000 USD to pay for the arrangement of the employment contracts, work visas and travel to Dubai. This practice is illegal (in actuality the employers are responsible for the fees) but the Emirate employers simply pay the agencies to bill the client and the government turns a blind eye. 

As the men are already living in poverty, they don’t have this kind of money and so they either take out loans from elsewhere or borrow directly from the unscrupulous agency recruiters, who know exactly what is going to happen to the men once they arrive in the UAE but do not care. This means that the men are in debt as soon as they arrive in the United Arab Emirates. 

The next step occurs when the men have arrived in Dubai. Their employers confiscate their passports, a practice that has been illegal since 2002 but is continued nevertheless. Officially, this holding of passports is supposedly for ‘security reasons’ to prevent workers from ‘absconding,’ but in reality it turns them into a prisoner, unable to escape. 

The final stage in this process is forcing the men to sign contracts, either in Arabic or English, with terms much different to what they initially agreed on back home. This is also illegal but happens across the board. By this stage, the men are helpless and the employer can treat them as he sees fit. 

dubai
IMG: Unsplash, Jens Oliver Meiert

THE PRACTICE 

Treatment of Construction Workers in Dubai

Accommodation

The accommodation provided to migrant workers in Dubai is barely habitable. Located an hour or more outside of the city, these squalid shanty towns or ‘labour camps’ (as they are known), are fetid hovels with overflowing toilets (I use this term loosely as usually the toilet is just a hole in the floor), no electricity and no air-conditioning or fans in the 50+ degree heat (122 degrees F). Eight to twelve men sleep in a room, often with five or more rooms in the house and one bathroom between everybody. 

Although the Dubai Municipality announced some ‘minimum standards’ for labour camps back in 2007 which saw some changes, many of the construction workers in Dubai have not seen any improvement. 

dubai construction workers sleeping in labour camps
Cramped conditions with men sleeping side by side on the floor.

IMG from The Coverage

Low Wages

One of the biggest complaints made by construction workers in Dubai is that the wages are far less than promised and impossible to live on. I received an email from a migrant worker in Dubai who said that he ‘knew a Pakistani roofer who was paid like $2 per hour to work in 50 degree weather exposed completely to the sun. And he worked 12 hour shifts, 7 days a week.’ 

This figure, amounting to $672 per month if the man was paid for all of the hours that he worked, is actually quite high – the average construction worker in Dubai gets just $175 per month for up to 12 hours a day, 6 or 7 days a week, with some workers being paid as little as $106 per month, or 0.35c per hour. This is a stark contrast to the average monthly salary of a Western expat, which is $8471 (of course, Western expats are usually working in more skilled jobs but there is no justification for such a huge discrepancy). 

Failure to Pay Wages

As with the confiscation of the passports, not paying workers is ‘custom’ in Dubai, and employers routinely hold the first 2 months wages as ‘security’ to prevent the worker from absconding. However, wages are often withheld for much longer than 2 months, with some workers not being paid for 6 months, or even a year

As soon as a workers’ wages are withheld for even 1 month, they immediately fall into arrears on the debt owed to the recruitment agencies back home, incurring interest on the already huge amounts owed. They also cannot send money back home to their families who desperately need it, and in addition to that, they have to borrow even more money from those around them just to be able to buy the food they need in order to survive. 

These men, who came to Dubai hoping to improve their financial situation, often end up in a far worse position than they were in back in their home countries. 

Hazardous Conditions

Perhaps the most troubling thing about the treatment of construction workers in Dubai is the hazardous conditions that they are forced to work in. In the UAE, temperatures often reach more than 50 degrees Celsius (122 Fahrenheit) with workers being exposed to the sun for hours at a time when tourists are warned not to stay outside for longer than 5 minutes. Although a law was made that limited the hours workers are allowed to spend outside in the summer months, this law is rarely enforced, with many companies openly flouting it and no fines being administered. Thousands of construction workers are admitted to A&E every month during the summertime in Dubai.  

It is almost no surprise that conditions on construction sites are so dangerous when we consider the fact that combined with the unforgiving heat, only 18% of construction companies in the Dubai Municipality conduct regular health and safety training, 63% of construction deaths in Dubai occur due to poor supervision and lack of training and 59% of all employees in Dubai are never issued a health and safety certificate (source).

instagram model in dubai
Unaware of the suffering behind the skyline

IMG: Rich Kids of Dubai Instagram

Death 

In 2004 alone, the embassies of India, Pakistan and Bangladesh returned the bodies of 880 construction workers back to their own countries (30% of which are thought to be on-site deaths), yet in the same year Dubai claimed that only 34 construction workers had died. The following year, India reported 971 deaths of Indian nationals in the United Arab Emirates, a number that has not been acknowledged by the UAE itself. With 71% of workers in the UAE having no way of reporting accidents, construction workers in Dubai are almost totally reliant on their employers reporting injuries and deaths to the authorities, something which they are clearly failing to do. This failure of companies to report the deaths of workers is part of the reason why conditions never improve – after all, if nobody is dying then it can’t be too hazardous, right? 

In addition to on-site deaths due to dangerous working conditions, suicide among migrant workers in the UAE is a huge problem. In fact, The Indian Consulate in Dubai revealed that at least 2 Indians commit suicide every week in the UAE, a number that is simultaneously both shocking yet unsurprising. 

Of course, suicide is a problem everywhere, being the leading cause of death for men under the age of 50. However, when the people taking their own lives are from the same minority in the same area doing the same type of job, there is something very very wrong. 

THE LAW 

How does the law enable slavery in Dubai to flourish?

The Kafala System

Part of what enables slavery in Dubai is the Kafala system. Kafala, which means ‘sponsorship’ in Arabic, with a sponsor being a kafeel, is a system popular in the Gulf countries that delegates the responsibility and oversight of workers to private citizens and companies as opposed to the government. The Kafala system not only requires workers to receive permission from their employer if they wish to change jobs, but it also requires a minimum of two years working for the same person or company. This of course helps enable wage suppression as there is effectively no competition. The migrant workers’ exit visa is also under the control of the kafeel, meaning that the worker cannot leave the country without their employer’s permission

This in itself renders the system wide open to abuse and exploitation, with migrant workers in Dubai being at the total mercy of their employers (particularly in the case of vulnerable domestic workers, which I will cover in a later article), but in addition to that, the Kafala system provides no protection for the workers. The Kafala system does not allow workers to dispute employers’ nonperformance of contracts, nor does it allow them to escape a potentially abusive situation. If a worker is caught trying to escape their employer then they are returned straight back to the same employer, who also has the right to cancel their residency, which would lead to detention and eventual deportation. 

All of the above totally strips the worker of their right to choose and puts the employer in the position of ‘slave owner,’ with the worker helpless to change the situation. 

The Kafala system is so barbaric that even the official UAE Labour Law website acknowledges that ‘it puts workers in vulnerable situations where they are dependent on their employer, which often leads to exploitation and abuse with little ability to seek outside assistance.’ (I implore you to take note of the use of the word ‘often’ in that sentence.)

In fact, in 2016 the UAE began implementing labour law reforms aimed at ‘eventually abolishing’ the Kafala system but the Human Rights Watch World Report 2019 found that the system continues to trap vulnerable workers in Dubai. 

A Lack of Investigation

Although the UAE Federal Labour Law provisions apply to both UAE nationals and migrant workers, the federal government of the UAE have completely failed to investigate, prosecute and remedy abusive and unlawful conduct by employers towards construction workers in Dubai. 

For example, although confiscating passports is illegal, it happens. Although forcing workers to pay for their own work visas and travel costs is illegal, it happens. Working for more than 8 hours a day (totaling 48 hours a week) is illegal but guess what? It happens. Although a minimum wage should have been implemented in 1980, there is still no minimum wage in the United Arab Emirates and no companies have been prosecuted for failing to implement a minimum wage. 

Part of the reason for this is that a Human Rights Watch report found that only 140 government inspectors were responsible for overseeing the labour practices of over 240,000 businesses that employ migrant workers. It doesn’t help that there are no independent organisations to monitor the construction sector, document abuse or advocate for human rights. 

boycott UAE
Protest against treatment of Asian workers in the UAE. It took place in New Delhi.

IMG: Boycott UAE

A Dodgy Appeals Process

While I would like to say that the only reason for the failure to prosecute unlawful employers is a lack of man power in the system (something that can be easily rectified), this is sadly not the case. 

My contact in Dubai told me that ‘The Dubai courts system is the main reason there are no labour rights for migrant workers in Dubai.’ The law is designed to protect the interests of employers and large companies at the expense of the worker, and this is apparent when we take a look at the appeals system. 

Although workers can legally seek a hearing in front of the Ministry of Labour if they feel as though their rights are being denied, it is not a simple process and government officials (including the Minister of Labour himself) have criticised this system, saying that it is ‘inadequate’ and ‘in need of urgent reform,’ also noting that it ‘protects the interests of construction companies and keeps no comprehensive information or statistics on cases.’ 

First of all, the migrant worker must make a complaint in writing to the Ministry of Labour, which, considering that the vast majority of South Asian construction workers in Dubai are illiterate and do not speak Arabic, is no easy feat. The worker I spoke to (who was in the middle of his own court case at the time of our correspondence) said ‘The bureaucracy makes it expensive to file a claim. You need to pay top dirham for Arabic translations.’ 

Of course, when most construction workers in the UAE are paid pitifully small amounts or even denied their wages altogether, this presents another obstacle.

He continued – ‘Cases take forever. This is not an accident, but on purpose to tire employees. In my own assessment it is not worth to go to court in Dubai if you are not seeking more than $30,000. A lawyer will cost at least $3000, and they don’t work on commissions for the most part.’ 

His comments on how difficult it is to even get a hearing paint a depressing picture, but even those lucky few who do make it to court, there is little hope for justice. In their investigation, the Human Rights Watch did not find a single occurrence of an employer being sanctioned for failing to pay workers, either with prison time or with a financial penalty. Even those workers who do succeed in obtaining a judgement against their employer do not manage to recover their unpaid wages, let alone see any kind of punishment to the guilty party.

THE CONCLUSION

I think, if you’ve made it this far, then you will find it impossible to deny that Dubai is a city built by slaves that continues to reap the benefits of their hard work while exploiting them more and more. 

This is not simply a case of low wages and long hours. This is not people taking bad jobs in order to put food on the table. This is slavery, through and through, at an institutionalised level. 

Modern slavery in Dubai is perpetuated by the privately owned companies in the construction sector and the unscrupulous agencies in the victims’ home countries. It is enabled by a government that doesn’t have the means, nor the desire to put a stop to it. The government of the United Arab Emirates cares nothing for human rights and human life, especially if that human is a poor, unskilled man from a small village in India or Pakistan. To the government of the UAE, construction workers are not people. They are tools to be used, exploited and disposed of when their bodies inevitably shut down. 

I will leave you with the words of my correspondent in Dubai: 

‘I have seen many cultures and countries, but only in Dubai have I seen true slavery. In Latin America [the man is from El Salvador] there is poverty and work exploitation, but poor people are better off. Only in Dubai have I seen employers confiscating your passport, not paying workers for 6 months straight, and forcing them to work 12 hours, 7 days a week in the sun outside.’

*compared to what they would receive back home.

SLAVERY IN DUBAI